The Issues
Our political system is like a poorly architected old building that is falling apart and infested with termites, at times making a mockery of democracy.
Some of the issues we face today are the subject of regular public debate: inadequate representation of all sections of society; freebies, cash and other inducements in election campaigns; divisive vote-bank politics and appeasements; and corruption and nepotism across departments and institutions.
There are several other problems that do not surface regularly in public debate: local strongmen getting elected to national and state legislatures, regardless of whether they have the vision and expertise required to serve at those levels; partisan voting on legislation; legislatures being unable to hold the executive accountable; parliamentary committee members lacking the expertise necessary to oversee executive departments; the PMO (and CMO in the states) often wielding more power than the Cabinet; persistent friction among the three branches of government, as well as between the states and the Centre; questions surrounding the independence and autonomy of constitutional offices such as the President of India and the Election Commission of India; and contentious issues such as delimitation.
Root Causes
But the good news is that these problems stem from weaknesses in just two structural elements: (1) constituency-based elections and (2) party-based politics. Addressing these two root causes can resolve the many problems listed above, some entirely and others in part.
Constituency-based elections
Constituency-based elections require people from all sections of society to elect a single representative, who can belong to only one community. Naturally, leaders from dominant communities, or their proxies in reserved constituencies, have an advantage, and other communities rarely see their own leaders in power.
Constituency-based elections reduce elections to national and state legislatures to local contests. Local leaders see them as arenas in which to establish their supremacy over one another in controlling local affairs. The result is that local strongmen get elected to national and state legislatures, regardless of whether they have the vision required for those bodies.
Constituency-based elections generally follow the First-Past-the-Post (FPTP) method, under which the candidate with the most votes wins. This is, no doubt, fair in principle, but there are problems with the way it plays out in practice. Leaders fight tooth and nail, using all sorts of tactics, and those unwilling to compromise their principles often get elbowed out before they can even enter the system.
FPTP a mismatch between vote share and seat share, giving the winning party far more power than its actual support among the electorate warrants. Winning candidates secure typically about 35% of the vote of the total electorate; a majority of the voters are never aligned with the elected leader as a consequence.
Political Parties
Electing political parties is essentially entrusting the governance of the nation (or the states) to private entities with their own agendas and ideologies. These entities routinely suffer from a lack of competent leadership and internal factionalism, while also being constrained by the expectations of the vote banks they cultivate. They put their own survival and well-being ahead of those of the nation, when push comes to shove.
Political parties monopolise the pathways to power. Leaders can hardly get elected without joining one, which means giving up their independent voice, toeing the party line, and supporting and defending all its leaders, past and present, as well as its ideologies, however outdated, flawed, or compromised. The performance, competence, and ethical standards of a party are ultimately constrained by those at the top.
Party-based politics also suffers from what we might call the ‘one-two-many’ problem. Sometimes, a single party dominates, leaving voters with no meaningful alternative, legislation without meaningful debate, and the executive without effective checks. Sometimes, two parties dominate, each with its own vote banks, polarising society and turning legislatures into theatres for political drama. At other times, multiple parties prevail, resulting in coalition governments that can be fragile, chaotic, unstable, and ineffective.
State governments may not enjoy the independence they need to function properly, when their own party is in power at the Centre. Tensions often prevail when different parties are in power at the Centre and in the states.
Striking at the Root
Having grown accustomed to constituency-based elections and political parties, we tend to think they are integral to politics, governance, and democracy itself. That is not necessarily so.
First, there are democracies around the world that follow variants of the Proportional Representation (PR) model that do not rely on territorial constituencies.
Second, democracy is about people governing themselves through their elected representatives. Political parties, on the other hand, are essentially pre-election alliances of those who seek power. Their historical roots lie in legislative factions. In fact, they are not constitutional institutions in the sense many people assume. The original Constitution made no reference to them; references to political parties were introduced later in the context of the anti-defection provisions. From a legal standpoint, they are private entities registered as associations under the Representation of the People Act, 1951.
Of these two root causes, constituency-based elections can be addressed by adopting a PR model that does not rely on territorial constituencies. But PR cannot solve the other problem: political parties. In fact, it legitimises them and makes them central to the political system. Hence, we need to look beyond FPTP and PR for better electoral models that overcome the shortcomings of both.
Systemic Solution
We propose a new electoral model called Multiple Representation (MR), designed to overcome the shortcomings of both FPTP and PR. It not only addresses the many problems facing our political system today but also lays the foundations for a new and vibrant democracy.
Under this model, voters would have multiple votes—say, twelve—which they could distribute among multiple leaders from anywhere in the nation, or anywhere in the state in state elections. Candidates would be ranked by their vote counts, and the top-ranked candidates (e.g. 543 for the Lok Sabha) would be declared elected. The voting power of the elected leaders would be proportional to their vote counts, which we call PVP (Proportional Voting Power).
The MR model, with no constituencies, releases various sections of the people with shared concerns and aspirations from the cages of constituencies. They can join together from across the nation (or state in state elections), along any shared interest, to elect leaders of their own.
Under this model, a woman from an agricultural family, for example, can choose one leader dedicated to farmers' issues, another committed to women's empowerment, another from her own community, and yet another known for tackling corruption. Similarly, a teacher from a Dalit community who is also Divyang can distribute his votes among leaders dedicated to Dalit upliftment, education, disability-related concerns, and perhaps even to causes like clean public toilets and toilets in trains.
Leaders, too, can pursue issues they are passionate about and win elections by appealing directly to the relevant sections of the population, without having to join a political party. This would eliminate the one-two-many problem. Debates in the legislatures would be issue-based rather than party-based. The head of the executive—the Prime Minister or Chief Minister—would no longer represent a political party and could work for the well-being of the nation or state without partisan concerns.
All sections of the population can elect their own leaders and find representation in proportion to their numbers. Voters who want to elect visionary and principled leaders can do so by coming together from across the nation.
This model elevates legislatures into “Leadership Councils”, where leaders with organic connections to every community, cause, and field can find a seat at the table.
To our knowledge, no country currently uses this kind of model. It is an innovation in electoral design, much as UPI was an innovation in digital payments.
The diagram here shows where MR would fit within the landscape of electoral models, using the classification developed by the International Institute for Democracy and Electoral Assistance (International IDEA), headquartered in Sweden, as a reference.
In an article that will soon be provided here, we will explore the MR model in depth, including how it seeks to address each of the issues identified above, how the concept of “Leadership Councils” can make our democracy more vibrant, and answers to many other questions that this draft may have prompted in the reader's mind.
We invite every political scientist, reformer, and leader to join the discussion, examine the MR model, explore its potential to address the issues plaguing our political system, and consider advocating for its adoption.
Nutan Vidhan